Move Over SEO, It’s Time for AIO

For over two decades, SEO (Search Engine Optimization) was the undisputed king of digital strategy – if you weren’t ranking on page one, you were practically invisible. But today, we’re witnessing a seismic shift in how people find information. Generative AI tools and AI-driven search experiences are turning traditional search on its head. Google’s own AI Overviews (the summarized answers at the top of results) have exploded – they appeared in just 13% of US search queries in March 2025 (up 102% from January). In parallel, millions of users have flocked to conversational AI assistants like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Claude to answer questions directly. In fact, ChatGPT now serves an estimated 500 million weekly users on its free. All of this signals one thing for marketers and content strategists: move over SEO, it’s time for AIO.

What do we mean by AIO (Artificial Intelligence Optimization)? In short, it’s the practice of optimizing your content to communicate effectively with AI systems – not just to rank in traditional search. Much like SEO forced us to cater to Google’s algorithms, AIO means ensuring your messages are understood and favored by the new generation of AI “audiences.” Think of AI like a new kind of opinion leader or intermediary: it reads our content, decides what’s relevant, and then conveys answers to users. If your content isn’t visible or credible to the AI, it might never reach the human searcher. As researchers at USC put it, “AIO isn’t just about disseminating messages, but about ensuring that these messages effectively ‘communicate’ with AI systems.” In other words, AI is becoming both a conduit and a gatekeeper – and brands must optimize for that reality.

Why AIO Matters for Marketers

Early data shows that ignoring AIO is not an option. Even though only ~13% of searches currently show AI overviews, their impact is outsized – these summaries often steal the attention that used to go to the top organic. Studies indicate AI-generated answers contribute to higher “zero-click” behavior (users getting info without clicking through) and have been blamed for drops in organic traffic. (One industry analysis found publishers’ Google traffic fell by up to 8% in early 2025, correlating with the rollout of AI answers.) Marketers are already responding. Publishers, for example, are recalibrating their SEO strategies after a year of AI Overviews – one publisher is backing off long-tail content aimed at search engines, another is doubling down on exclusive news, and a third is actively reducing reliance on Google traffic. The common thread: simply chasing traditional SEO rankings is no longer enough when the answer box at the top might cherry-pick and repackage content from across the web.

At the same time, AIO presents opportunities. Google reports that users who engage with AI Overviews end up searching more often – in markets like the US and India, queries that trigger AI responses have driven a 10% increase in Google usage. That suggests if your content is featured in AI results, you could still gain visibility or traffic in new ways (albeit harder to measure). There’s also evidence that strong SEO still pays dividends in the AI era. A recent study of 25,000 searches found that websites holding the #1 Google position appeared in 25% of AI-generated answers on platforms like ChatGPT and Perplexity. In other words, high-authority pages are often the ones being quoted by AI, so good old-fashioned quality and relevance remain critical. The goal of AIO is to ensure your brand is the one the AI chooses to quote or cite. That means focusing on E-E-A-T factors (Experience, Expertise, Authority, Trustworthiness) and structured, factual content that algorithms recognize as reliable. It also means technical tweaks: for instance, making sure your content is easily crawlable by AI models and that you’re using proper schema/metadata – essentially, feed the AI good data about your content.

Perhaps the biggest shift is mindset. As Mike King recently noted, in classic search your content “comes out the same way it goes in,” but with generative AI, your content can be manipulated, summarized, or combined in ways you don’t directly control. You might do all the right SEO things and still find that the user only sees an AI-generated blurb of your article. This is why King argues that “SEO as it currently exists is not enough.” We need to optimize not just for blue links, but for algorithmic visibility – making our content AI-ready so that even when it’s remixed by a chatbot or an overview, our brand and message aren’t lost. In practice, this could involve strategies like: writing concise Q&A style content that AI can easily pull into a direct answer; ensuring your brand is mentioned in contexts the AI might use (for example, having experts from your company quoted, to increase the chance an AI cites your site as a source); and monitoring the contexts in which your content gets referenced by AI.

The InsightFlow Perspective – and How We Can Help

At InsightFlow, we’ve been closely tracking this evolution from SEO to AIO. Our take is straightforward: AIO is now a core part of marketing and content strategy, and those who master it early will leap ahead. Why? Because getting your content in front of your audience now requires pleasing two audiences – humans and AI. Just as you once asked “how will this play with users and the Google algorithm?”, you now must consider AI-driven platforms in that mix. In fact, we view algorithms and AI models as a new kind of audience persona – one that has huge influence over your human. Optimizing for AI doesn’t mean writing for robots at the expense of people; it means making your content the most credible, clear source for the topics you cover, so that AI systems choose to present your information. It’s about aligning with how AI evaluates content: relevance, factual accuracy, authority signals, and even technical accessibility.

This shift impacts day-to-day marketing tactics. Keyword strategy is giving way to answer strategy – instead of just “How do I rank for X query?”, we’re asking “What questions will the AI be answering on this topic, and how do I become the answer?” Ensuring your content is used in AI Overviews or voice assistants might require creating deeper FAQ sections, providing step-by-step explainer content, or using schema markup (for things like HowTo or QAPage) to increase your chances of being picked up. Brand-building matters even more: if an AI is synthesizing answers from many sources, you want your brand to be one that’s cited (Google’s AI Overviews do provide source links). That means establishing your site as a trusted authority in your niche. We also can’t overlook analytics – with AI, the metrics of success are shifting. For example, Google Search Console now reports AI Overview impressions/clicks in a collapsed way (all sources in an overview count as one position), making it trickier to gauge impact. Marketers need new KPIs (like share of AI citations, or traffic from chatbots) to truly understand performance in the AI-driven landscape.

InsightFlow’s platform is built to help marketers navigate this new landscape. We aggregate and automate reporting across all your data sources – from classic web analytics and SEO tools to social and beyond. This unified view is crucial when your traffic might be coming from a mix of traditional search, AI assistants, voice queries, and more. For instance, our dashboards can combine Google Analytics, Search Console, and third-party data to highlight if a dip in organic traffic coincides with an uptick in zero-click AI answers on the SERP. We enable you to track these patterns in minutes, not weeks, so you can respond quickly. Our advanced analytics engine uses machine learning to surface “hidden” patterns, exactly the kind of intelligence you need when figuring out how an AI feature might be siphoning or redirecting your traffic. And while AI is disrupting search, we use AI on our end too: InsightFlow’s tools can automatically pull key insights from your data (for example, detecting if certain high-ranking pages are suddenly losing clicks possibly due to AI results). In short, we help you measure what matters in the AIO era.

The bottom line: SEO isn’t dead, but it’s evolving. We’re entering an era of AI Optimization (AIO) where success means blending the art of content creation with the science of algorithm understanding. Marketers and CMOs who recognize this shift can turn it into a competitive advantage. It’s a time to be data-driven and experiment – monitor how your content is performing in these new AI contexts and adjust accordingly. And remember, while algorithms might change, the end goal remains the same: delivering the information and value your audience needs. Now, it just so happens that your audience has a new member – the AI middleman. It’s time to make that new “audience” your ally.

What We’re Reading

• Is SEO Still Relevant In The AI Era? New Research Says Yes – A study by the Search Engine Journal of 25,000 searches finds that the #1 Google result appears in 25% of ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other AI search answers, indicating traditional SEO rankings still strongly influence AI-driven results.

• Google Fixes AI Mode Traffic Attribution Bug – Google resolved an issue where its new AI search mode traffic was being mislabeled as “direct” in analytics, reports the Search Engine Journal. Marketers’ organic traffic from AI search should now be properly tracked, restoring clarity to performance data.

• OpenAI’s Bold Vision for ChatGPT Seems Poised for a Familiar Business Model: Ads – As generative AI usage grows, OpenAI appears ready to embrace advertising. This piece by Digiday notes that only ~4% of ChatGPT’s 500 million weekly users pay for a subscription, and adds that OpenAI expects to lose $44 billion by 2029 – pressure that makes an ad-supported model likely in order to monetize the other 96% of users.

• How AI Mode Works and How SEO Can Prepare for the Future of Search – An in-depth look at Google’s new “AI Mode” by SEO veteran Mike King (iPullRank). He explains why generative AI in search fundamentally changes content visibility – unlike traditional search, AI can rewrite or combine your content, so “SEO as it currently exists is not enough” and marketers must adapt tactics to ensure their content survives in an AI-transformed SERP.

• Google Search ‘AI Mode’ Seen as Content Theft by Publishers – This report by Coywolf covers growing concern from news publishers that Google’s more advanced AI answers (AI Mode) will further erode referral traffic. Industry reps even dub it a form of “content theft,” since the AI may satisfy users’ queries by scraping content without click-through – posing an existential threat to publishers if traffic and ad revenues decline.

From the Blog

InsightFlow Analytics: Your Partner in Data-Informed Growth

We’re here to partner with you in your data-informed decision-making. Our features make a difference, from collecting data and organizing your work to saving searches, we make it easy to start data-informed growth.

• Capture your data, put it in your workspace, and share it with others

• Find topics through fast, effective searches

• Create documents based on your data-informed research

• Organize and tag your data

• Connect your hard work and visualize it through a knowledge graph

• Collaborate through team spaces

Get started with your data-informed strategy. We can help you take the first step by introducing you to the tools that you need in your toolkit. If data is not a part of your decision-making process, you are already behind. We are here to help you catch up and lead the way.

Sign up for a demo or trial of InsightFlow Analytics. Be sure to share this newsletter with your peers, too.

Stay connected with us and share your input!

📲 Keep up with InsightFlow Analytics on LinkedIn, Instagram, X and Facebook. Send comments and suggestions to [email protected].

💭 At InsightFlow Analytics, we harness the power of strategic marketing to help brands tell their stories, connect with their audiences, and drive impactful results. Learn more about us.